Italian Bread Pudding with Condensed Milk Sauce

This Italian bread pudding with condensed milk sauce is a very simple and easy to make Italian dessert. It uses stale bread, golden raisins, eggs, sugar and milk which is baked in the oven and topped with a rich sweetened condensed milk sauce. 

These individual bread pudding cups with a simple vanilla condensed milk sauce are a great treat to entertain with and simple enough to make when you are craving something sweet.

Jump to Recipe

Total Time: 45 minutes

What is Italian Bread Pudding?

Italian bread pudding is very similar to American bread pudding. It usually has golden raisins and the Italian bread pudding is most often made with a creme anglaise type of sauce.

This type of traditional sauce is a little more involved and not exactly quick to make. For this bread pudding recipe, the vanilla sauce has been simplified by using condensed milk with some butter, vanilla and milk.

Having a simple vanilla sauce for bread pudding is much easier for the everyday cook.  I feel very confident in saying that it tastes better too!

Another main difference with this Italian bread pudding recipe is there is no cinnamon added. It does however require the same basic ingredients to soften up stale bread and transform it into something that tastes so amazing.

I love this Italian dessert so much because I hate to throw out any food (unless it goes bad.) Getting to eat dessert and making sure I am not wasting food is a win win here.

The bread for this Italian bread pudding:

This bread pudding with condensed milk sauce uses stale baguette bread. If you do not have stale bread or cannot wait to make the recipe then store bought baguette from the bakery section (without any toppings or butter) can be used.

Just make sure to leave it out on the counter overnight to toughen up.

Remember, the more preservatives that are in the bread, the longer it will take to get stale. Basically, all natural bread is not only better for you but better for your bread puddings!

Another important note about the type of stale bread to use is you want stale bread that is tough and not dry. If you have bread that dried out too much like a crouton then that would not taste as good.

Stale and chewy is the name of the game for bread pudding.

Ingredients you will need to make this Italian Bread Pudding recipe are:

• eggs
• stale bread
• milk
• butter
• sugar
• golden raisins (optional but recommended)
• For the vanilla sauce for the bread pudding- sweetened condensed milk, butter, milk and vanilla

Many of these ingredients for this bread pudding with condensed milk sauce can be substituted based on your preference. If you cannot find golden raisins, you can use regular purple raisins.

If you need a dairy free alternative for the milk or condensed milk, then you can sub out the regular milk for dairy free milk.

Even the sweetened condensed milk sauce can be adjusted by just using coconut condensed milk!

About the vanilla sauce for this Italian bread pudding recipe:

This condensed milk sauce (my simple vanilla sauce) that I created for this bread pudding recipe was born out of laziness and not wanting to make a traditional complex vanilla sauce. I have to say that in this instance, my laziness really paid off!

My quick vanilla sauce is made with sweetened condensed milk, a touch of butter, vanilla and milk. Yup, canned sweetened condensed milk!

I don't think there is any dessert or breakfast (like my baked french toast casserole) that doesn't taste better with condensed milk. I will even make this condensed milk sauce on its own for cakes.

This simple vanilla sauce is one my favorite sauces for desserts and the uses are absolutely endless. You can add it to ice cream, cake, bread pudding or any other things you can think of needing a sweet decadent and lush sauce.

I love it even more because it is so easy to make. I just don't think cooking should be complicated.

As I mentioned above, if you are on a dairy free diet, you can totally use a coconut condensed milk in place of the regular condensed milk. It is really delicious both ways!

What I love about this bread pudding with condensed milk sauce

• It is so simple to make.
• It tastes amazing.
• That vanilla condensed milk sauce is addictive (make extra, trust me). If you want, you can skip straight to the bread pudding sauce
• It is made in individual portion sizes so everyone can eat their portion when they want.

For More Italian Dessert Recipes:

• Italian Pizzelles are a classic cookie made at family gatherings and holidays. Growing up, these were made every Sunday for our Italian family gatherings.
• My cookie press Pizzelle cookies that are made with the same dough you make a pizzelle with but you do not need a special pizzelle maker for this one. So delicious!
• Italian basil olive cake. This is one of my favorite cakes to make and it is as easy as blending everything together and pouring into a pan.
• Italian Berry Cake with Mascarpone Cream. This is a light wonderful layer cake that looks beautiful but is very easy to make.
• Italian Plum Tart. This is one of my favorites when plums are in season.
• Italian Pizzelle Cannoli are really delicious and simple cannoli made with rolled pizzelles and the most delicious cannoli cream.

What if I do not have individual ramekins?

This is a question I get asked often. If you do not have individual ramekins, you can combine this whole recipe for the four servings into a small square baking dish, about 8"x8".

If you are using a round baking dish then a small round 6"x2" dish.

Add five minutes of cooking time to the recipe and then test for doneness by inserting a toothpick into center and it comes out clean. If it is still wet just add another 5 minutes or so until it is cooked through.

I will say that ramekins are so invaluable in my kitchen. If you do not have ramekins I would definitely try to add those to your kitchen wishlist since they come in handy for some many things!

It is best served warm once it has rested for a few  minutes after coming out of the oven.

Should bread pudding be served hot or cold?

You always want to serve your bread pudding almost right out of the oven. Just remove it from the oven and let it sit for a couple minutes before serving.

Can I make my bread stale for this recipe if I do not have stale bread?

You can speed up the process of bread going stale by placing your bread on a baking sheet and into a pre-heated 325 degree oven for about 5-10 minutes. Just check it every few minutes and make sure it is not turning into a crouton but just getting dried out a bit.

Can this bread pudding be made ahead of time?

Yes this bread pudding can be made ahead of time. If follow all of the recipe all the way through baking, just let the bread pudding come to room temp after it is done cooking.

At this point, place some aluminum foil over the tops and store in your fridge for up to 2 days.

To re-heat, remove from the fridge about a half hour before warming. When ready to warm, place your ramekins on a large baking sheet and cover with aluminum foil.

Then place into a pre-heated 325 degree oven and bake for 10-15 minutes or until warmed all the way through.