documenting recipes of real food and great ingredients

S’mores Pie Homemade Holiday Gift

S’mores Pie Homemade Holiday Gift

S’mores pie homemade holiday gifts is the best gift you can give someone at the holidays. It is the perfect way to spoil someone special and totally economical. You can throw in some homemade golden milk mix as well as an additional hostess treat.

Ok, I have a confession.  I am not a big fan of s’mores.  Really.  It is a tradition to eat in the summer but it is not my favorite and no matter how many times I have tried it, I have never been wowed. 

Then enters this recipe!  This s’mores recipe is a game changer for me!  When I tried this for the first time, I was in LOVE!  Now, I cannot take credit for this amazing creation. 

I found this on a website called Mostly Homemade Mom and huge amounts of praise should be going that way for thinking of this!  The reason this recipe is soooo good is because the crust is made with graham crackers, brown sugar, butter and flour and it almost tastes like shortbread – YUM. 

I realized that I didn’t like traditional s’mores because of the plain graham cracker flavor and this recipe changes all of that.  It. Is. Good!

Since I have made this s’mores pie recipe many times (so has my daughter) and it is eaten up, raved about and requested all the time, I decided to make these into homemade gifts for the holiday season.  I just know that the people I give these to are going to love them!

Here is what you need to make one of these holiday gifts that makes one full sized smore’s pie:

  • a mason jar
  • small plastic bags with twist ties or that seals (this holds the marshmallows and chocolate separately).
  • flour
  • brown sugar
  • marshmallows
  • chocolate chips
  • graham crackers

This recipe is for making one edible holiday gift. I love making an entire assembly line of ingredients and make a bunch of these as gifts to give out. If you are already doing the work for one it is just easier to do multiple ones.

This makes a edible homemade gift is great for:

  • Teachers
  • hostess gift
  • family
  • friends (especially those who think they can’t bake because this one is fool proof)
  • teens (what teen doesn’t love a sweet dessert!)

When you make this gift, don’t forget to print out the notes section of the recipe and include that with the gift. This is the instructions for the gift recipient on how to make the s’mores pie.

If you are looking for an amazing s’mores recipe or a heart felt holiday gift this season then give these a try!

S’mores Pie Homemade Holiday Gift

A delicious food gift to give during the holidays
Prep Time30 mins
Cook Time0 mins
Printing out labels with recipe instructions for gifts10 mins
Total Time4 mins
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Servings: 1 jar


  • 1/2 cup brown sugar
  • 1 cup flour
  • 1/2 cup graham cracker crumbs
  • 1 cup milk chocolate chips
  • 1 cup miniature marshmallows
  • 1 quart sized Ball Jar
  • 2 small clear plastic decorative bags for packaging marshmallows and chocolate chips I find these at my local arts and craft store in the cookie isle


  • Directions for making the jar holiday gift:
  • Fill a small clear plastic cookie bag with your marshmallows and seal with a twist tie or knot.
  • Fill a small clear plastic cookie bag with your chocolate chips and seal with a twist tie or knot.
  • In a medium bowl, measure out your graham crackers, brown sugar and flour and mix well.
  • Now place your mixture on a sheet of parchment paper or similar and fold in half and carefully pour mixture into your glass jars.
  • Next, add your chocolate chip bag into the jar. You may have to wiggle it around a bit to get it in there.
  • Now, add your marshmallow bag into the jar. Again, a little wiggling may be necessary.
  • Seal your jar with a tight fitting lid and add any decorations you wish!
  • Print our this recipe and cut out the instructions on how to make the s'mores pie (in the notes section of recipe) and attach these instructions to a card and attach to the gift


Directions to make s’more pie:
What you will Need-
1/2 cup butter melted
To Make-
Pre-heat your oven to 375 degrees. In a large bowl mix together butter and your brown sugar/flour/graham cracker mixture in jar. Press evenly into a 9 x 9 square baking dish or pie dish that has been coated with non stick spray. Sprinkle your chocolate chips and marshmallows evenly over the top of your graham cracker mixture. Bake for 12 to 15 minutes or until the marshmallows start to get a golden brown color. Cool completely. When ready to eat, coat a knife with non stick spray and slice.

You May Also Like

Cardamom Shortbread Cookies with Dark Chocolate and Coconut

Cardamom shortbread
Shortbread cookies with hints of cardamom, chocolate and coconut
Check out this recipe

Coconut Milk Fudge Bars

fudge bars
A delicious and refreshing homemade fudge bar that is creamy and so much better than store bought. This recipes makes 4-6 popsicles depending on size.
Check out this recipe

Related Posts

Easy and Delicious Citrus Snowball Cookies

Easy and Delicious Citrus Snowball Cookies

I have been making these citrus snowball cookies as my family’s Christmas cookies for years because they are so amazing. This dough is actually for my regular cutout sugar cookies and I adapted it to this easy recipe. This citrus snowball cookie recipe was something […]

Citrus Holiday Cookies

Citrus Holiday Cookies

Citrus holiday cookies are a yearly tradition around here and something everyone looks forward to at the holidays. The citrus cookie dough is very forgiving and can be made into more than cutout cookies. With this one dough you will be on your way to […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating